[{"_1":2,"_78":-5,"_79":-5},"loaderData",{"_3":4},"routes/blog._index",{"_5":6,"_74":9,"_75":9,"_76":77},"posts",[7],{"_8":9,"_10":11,"_12":13,"_14":-5,"_15":16,"_17":18,"_19":20,"_21":22,"_23":16,"_24":25,"_26":27,"_28":29,"_30":29,"_31":32,"_33":34,"_35":36,"_37":38,"_39":40,"_41":42,"_43":44,"_45":46,"_64":65},"id",1,"slug","wim-hof-safety-contraindications","locale","en","translationOfId","title","Wim Hof Safety: The Three Hard Contraindications","excerpt","Wim Hof breathing is unsafe in water, during pregnancy, and without a doctor's clearance for cardiovascular, seizure, or severe panic conditions. The mechanism behind each rule, with sources.","content","

Wim Hof breathing is unsafe in three situations, no exceptions: in or near water (bath, shower, pool, ice bath, ocean), during pregnancy, and without a doctor's clearance if you have cardiovascular disease, uncontrolled hypertension, a seizure disorder, or a history of severe panic attacks. In healthy adults practicing on dry land, short sessions are generally well-tolerated. But the technique produces real, measurable physiological shifts, not a gentle relaxation effect. Here is what the published evidence shows, which sensations are expected, and which ones mean stop now.

\n\n\n\n\n\n

Why Wim Hof breathing hits the body harder than slow breathing

\n\n

The Wim Hof Method combines roughly 30 fast deep breaths, a breath-hold on empty lungs, and a recovery inhale held for around 15 seconds. It isn't a variant of box breathing. It's a deliberate autonomic challenge. Kox et al., 2014 (PNAS, N=12 trained practitioners plus 12 controls) measured voluntary sympathetic nervous system activation in WHM practitioners and an attenuated inflammatory cytokine response after an endotoxin challenge. The study is small, recruited mostly healthy young adults, and has not been replicated in clinical populations, but it remains the strongest peer-reviewed evidence that the technique produces genuine physiological effects rather than relaxation alone.

\n\n

The sensations most practitioners notice during a session (tingling fingers or lips, mild lightheadedness, occasional muscle tension called tetany) come from respiratory alkalosis. Laffey and Kavanagh's 2002 New England Journal of Medicine review on hypocapnia describes the mechanism. Rapid breathing drops arterial CO2, which raises blood pH, constricts cerebral blood vessels (roughly 2 to 4 percent reduction in cerebral blood flow per mmHg drop in PaCO2), and shifts ionized-calcium equilibrium enough to excite peripheral nerves. The cerebral vasoconstriction is why you feel lightheaded. The calcium shift is why your hands tingle.

\n\n

In healthy adults, these effects reverse within a few minutes of normal breathing. In specific populations, they don't reverse cleanly, or they interact with an underlying condition in a way that matters clinically. That's where the contraindications come from, and it's why \"just shorten the session\" isn't an adequate answer for the groups below.

\n\n

The three hard contraindications

\n\n

\"Hard\" means no clearance clause makes these situations safe. Three categories apply here. Water comes first, because a bathtub fainting event is fatal. Pregnancy comes second, because the maternal physiology and the clinical exercise guidance both point to skipping. The third category covers conditions that require a doctor's explicit sign-off, which I enumerate in the table below.

\n\n

\"A — Every visible exhale moves CO2 out of the bloodstream. Fast breathing moves it out faster than the body wants, which is what triggers the vasoconstriction and calcium shift above (Laffey and Kavanagh, 2002).

\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n

Situation	Mechanism	What to do
In or near water (bath, shower, pool, ocean, ice bath)	Voluntary hyperventilation suppresses the CO2-driven urge to breathe. During a subsequent breath-hold, blood oxygen can fall to syncope threshold before the urge to breathe returns. Fainting in water leads to drowning.	Never, no exceptions.
Pregnancy	Maternal hypocapnia can reduce placental blood flow, and extended retention transiently lowers oxygen delivery. Pregnancy is also not a tested population for WHM.	Skip Wim Hof entirely. Slow diaphragmatic breathing is generally fine, but check with your OB.
Cardiovascular disease, uncontrolled hypertension, arrhythmia, recent cardiac event	The fast-breathing phase produces a sympathetic surge (rising adrenaline, transient heart rate and blood pressure rise). In someone with an underlying cardiac condition, that surge can be clinically significant.	Cardiologist clearance required, with a default to no.
Seizure disorder or history of hyperventilation-induced seizures	Hyperventilation is used routinely in EEG labs to provoke absence seizures. The mechanism is identical in a living room.	Avoid. Talk to a neurologist if you want to reconsider.
Severe panic disorder or PTSD with hyperventilation triggers	The sympathetic surge phase replicates the physiological state of a panic attack and can trigger one rather than prevent it.	Trauma-informed clinician first. Start with slow breathing, not Wim Hof.
Eating disorders with severe hypoglycemia or electrolyte instability	WHM practices (especially fasted) can destabilize blood glucose and electrolytes.	Screen with a clinician first.

\n\n

The shallow-water blackout mechanism is worth understanding in detail, because \"fainting in a bathtub is fatal\" sounds like alarmism until you see the physiology. Craig's 1961 paper in the Journal of Applied Physiology (a canonical diving-medicine reference, corroborated across decades of aquatic-medicine literature) showed that voluntary hyperventilation before a breath-hold does not meaningfully raise oxygen stores. What it does is suppress the CO2-driven respiratory drive, which is the signal that normally tells you to inhale before you lose consciousness. Silence it, and the practitioner can lose consciousness before the urge to breathe ever returns. The Divers Alert Network names voluntary hyperventilation before breath-hold as the primary avoidable cause of shallow-water blackout, and the Wim Hof organization's own published safety guidance lists \"never in or near water\" as rule one.

\n\n

And the seizure warning isn't hypothetical. Hyperventilation is one of the standard provocations used during routine EEG testing to unmask absence seizure activity, per American Clinical Neurophysiology Society technical standards. Replicating the same provocation at home, voluntarily, in someone with a known seizure disorder is inadvisable by exactly the physiology that makes it a useful clinical test.

\n\n

The pregnancy guidance comes from a different kind of source. ACOG has not issued a WHM-specific statement. But its general committee opinion on exercise during pregnancy supports skipping activities with hypoxia or syncope risk, which is where the WHM breath-retention phase falls. That's why the recommendation is \"skip WHM and do slow patterns instead,\" not \"all breathwork is contraindicated.\"

\n\n

Finally, the screened-cohort trials. Buijze et al., 2019 (PLOS ONE, N=24 axial spondyloarthritis) ran an 8-week WHM training program and reported no serious adverse events. But the participants were screened against cardiovascular, seizure, and psychiatric conditions first, so the absence of adverse events is not evidence that the contraindications are over-cautious. And Almahayni and Hammond's 2024 systematic review in PLOS ONE concluded that most published WHM trials are small and run in healthy adult practitioners (rather than in the populations above). The honest summary: the evidence base does not tell us the technique is safe for unscreened cardiovascular, pregnant, or seizure-prone readers. It tells us we don't know, which is a different thing.

\n\n

Softer cautions that warrant a conversation with your doctor

\n\n

These situations are not absolute contraindications. They warrant a doctor conversation before trying Wim Hof specifically (slow diaphragmatic patterns are a different story and usually fine).

\n\n

Mild asthma. Slow breathing and resonance breathing are generally well-tolerated. Rapid-breathing protocols like WHM can trigger bronchoconstriction in some people. If your asthma is well-controlled, your pulmonologist can give you a specific green or red light.
Blood-pressure medications, beta blockers, or other heart-rate-altering drugs. The sympathetic surge phase can interact with these. A cardiologist's conditional okay is worth more than a blog's opinion.
Recent surgery (chest, abdominal, cardiac). Wait for full clearance from the operating surgeon, then reintroduce gently.
Mild anxiety without diagnosed panic disorder. Slow breathing usually helps. WHM is a different animal. Start with box or resonance and stay there until those feel familiar.
Age 60 and above, or a family history of cardiac events. Not a ban, but a reason to start very slowly and ideally under supervision.

\n\n

The Cleveland Clinic's patient-facing guidance on the Wim Hof Method echoes this picture. It acknowledges that the technique may have real physiological effects, then advises caution in anyone with cardiovascular, seizure, or psychiatric history, and explicitly recommends a doctor conversation first.

\n\n

Which sensations are expected, and which are warning signs

\n\n

Most people doing WHM for the first time notice something unusual. Some of those sensations are predictable responses to respiratory alkalosis in a healthy nervous system. Others are signals to stop immediately. Distinguishing one from the other matters more than the session length.

\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n

Sensation	What it means	What to do
Tingling in hands, feet, or around the lips	Normal alkalosis response (the ionized-calcium shift from Laffey and Kavanagh, 2002)	Expected. Shorten the next round if uncomfortable.
Mild lightheadedness during or after fast breathing	Cerebral vasoconstriction from lower CO2	Expected. Sit down, then do the next round more slowly.
Hand or jaw cramping (tetany)	More pronounced alkalosis. Not medically dangerous in healthy adults but a clear signal of intensity.	Stop this session. Normal breathing for two minutes.
Small involuntary movements during retention	Common at deeper retention levels, not harmful in healthy adults.	Allowed if the session still feels controlled. Stop if it escalates.
Chest pain or tightness	Possibly cardiac. Assume cardiac until proven otherwise.	Stop now. Emergency services if it persists.
Actual fainting or near-syncope	Cerebral hypoperfusion beyond the normal range	Stop. Do not practice unassisted for 24 hours. Emergency services if it happened in water.
Panic symptoms (racing heart plus fear, not just tingling)	Sympathetic surge triggering a panic response	Stop. Box breathing (4-4-4-4) to bring the system back. Seek trauma-informed support if recurring.

\n\n

Tetany is the most dramatic sensation most practitioners encounter, and because it looks alarming, it's the one most often misread as something medically serious. In a healthy adult, it isn't medically serious. Tetany is your alkalotic pH temporarily changing how calcium binds in your blood, and it signals that the session has gone about as far as it should.

\n\n

What to do if something goes wrong mid-session

\n\n

Mild lightheadedness. Stop the fast-breathing phase. Sit or lie down. Breathe normally for one to three minutes. Most practitioners recover fully in under five.
Tetany or muscle cramping. End the session. Shake out your hands. Normal breathing reverses the alkalosis and the sensation within minutes.
Near-fainting or full syncope. Lie down with your legs raised. If you fainted fully, or fainted in or near water, go to emergency services. Do not practice alone for the next 24 hours.
Panic symptoms. Stop and switch to box breathing at comfortable counts (four seconds in, four hold, four out, four hold), and use a grounding exercise like naming five things you can see. If this happens more than once, talk to a trauma-informed clinician before returning to WHM.
Chest pain. Stop and assume cardiac until proven otherwise. If it persists for more than a minute or two, call emergency services.

\n\n

When to call a doctor before trying again

\n\n

Call or message your doctor (or the relevant specialist) before resuming WHM if any of these describe you:

\n\n

Any chest pain during or after a session, ever.
Recurring lightheadedness or pre-syncope even during slow breathing.
Pregnancy, especially a high-risk one.
A known cardiovascular condition without prior clearance for breath-holds.
Panic disorder, PTSD, or a trauma history without a trauma-informed clinician.
A seizure disorder or a first-degree family history of seizures.
Breathwork that's making your symptoms worse over time instead of better.

\n\n

Safety across the major techniques

\n\n

Not every breathing pattern carries WHM's risk profile. A quick picture for context:

\n\n

Box breathing (4-4-4-4). Safe for nearly everyone. Rarely triggers problems. Exception: some panic-prone practitioners find any breath-hold uncomfortable at first.
4-7-8 breathing. Also safe for most readers. The long exhale can occasionally feel triggering for panic-prone practitioners, who often find box breathing easier to start with.
Resonance or coherent breathing (around 6 breaths per minute). The most gently tolerated of the slow patterns. Close to no contraindications outside active respiratory illness.
Rapid-breathing pranayama (bhastrika, kapalabhati). Shares several WHM contraindications because it uses rapid breathing. Traditional guidance (and most modern yoga teachers) recommends learning these under supervision.
Breath-holds generally. Never in water, never to exhaustion, and never while driving.

\n\n

How BreathSesh handles the Wim Hof problem

\n\n

BreathSesh labels Wim Hof as an advanced pattern and shows an in-app safety block on first use. The guided mode has fixed retention options (30, 60, or 90 seconds) so a beginner isn't tempted to push further than they should. Freestyle mode (tap to release) is deliberately separated for experienced practitioners who've already read the contraindications above. Every pattern runs offline without an account, which matters here because the safety block runs as a check that you've actually read the contraindications above, not a gate you tap through.

\n\n

The bottom line

\n\n

The Wim Hof Method produces real physiological effects, which is exactly why a \"hard\" contraindication list exists for it. Dry-land practice in a screened, healthy adult is generally well-tolerated. Water practice is not safe. Neither is pregnancy. Neither are the cardiovascular, seizure, and severe-panic populations. The mechanism is the same in each case, and the clinical literature has been describing that mechanism for over sixty years. If you're unsure which category you fall into, that alone is a reason to start with slow diaphragmatic breathing and talk to a clinician before you touch the fast-breathing phase.

","contentPlain","Wim Hof breathing is unsafe in three situations, no exceptions: in or near water, during pregnancy, and without a doctor's clearance if you have cardiovascular disease, uncontrolled hypertension, a seizure disorder, or a history of severe panic attacks. In healthy adults practicing on dry land, short sessions are generally well-tolerated. But the technique produces real physiological shifts, not a gentle relaxation effect. Here is what the published evidence shows, which sensations are expected, and which ones mean stop now.\n\nNote: This is educational content, not medical advice. Talk to a doctor before using breathwork for a diagnosed condition.\n\nSafety first. Never practice Wim Hof breathing in or near water (bath, shower, pool, ocean) fainting can be fatal. Skip it during pregnancy. If you have cardiovascular disease, high blood pressure, a seizure disorder, or a history of panic attacks, talk to a doctor before trying it.\n\n## Why Wim Hof breathing hits the body harder than slow breathing\n\nThe Wim Hof Method combines roughly 30 fast deep breaths, a breath-hold on empty lungs, and a recovery inhale held for around 15 seconds. It isn't a variant of box breathing. It's a deliberate autonomic challenge. Kox et al., 2014 (PNAS, N=12 trained practitioners plus 12 controls) measured voluntary sympathetic nervous system activation in WHM practitioners and an attenuated inflammatory cytokine response after an endotoxin challenge. The study is small, recruited mostly healthy young adults, and has not been replicated in clinical populations, but it remains the strongest peer-reviewed evidence that the technique produces genuine physiological effects.\n\nThe sensations most practitioners notice during a session (tingling fingers or lips, mild lightheadedness, tetany) come from respiratory alkalosis. Laffey and Kavanagh's 2002 New England Journal of Medicine review on hypocapnia describes the mechanism. Rapid breathing drops arterial CO2, which raises blood pH, constricts cerebral blood vessels (roughly 2 to 4 percent reduction in cerebral blood flow per mmHg drop in PaCO2), and shifts ionized-calcium equilibrium enough to excite peripheral nerves. The cerebral vasoconstriction is why you feel lightheaded. The calcium shift is why your hands tingle.\n\nIn healthy adults, these effects reverse within a few minutes of normal breathing. In specific populations, they don't reverse cleanly, or they interact with an underlying condition in a way that matters clinically. That's where the contraindications come from.\n\n## The three hard contraindications\n\n\"Hard\" means no clearance clause makes these situations safe. Three categories apply here. Water comes first, because a bathtub fainting event is fatal. Pregnancy comes second, because the maternal physiology and the clinical exercise guidance both point to skipping. The third category covers conditions that require a doctor's explicit sign-off.\n\n[Image: A plume of exhaled breath blooms into white vapor against a dark forest, the visible trace of an exhale in cold morning air.]\n\n- In or near water (bath, shower, pool, ocean, ice bath): Voluntary hyperventilation suppresses the CO2-driven urge to breathe. Blood oxygen can fall to syncope threshold before the urge to breathe returns. Fainting in water leads to drowning. Action: Never, and no clearance clause changes that.\n- Pregnancy: Maternal hypocapnia can reduce placental blood flow, and extended retention transiently lowers oxygen delivery. Pregnancy is not a tested population for WHM. Action: Skip Wim Hof entirely. Slow diaphragmatic breathing is generally fine, but check with your OB.\n- Cardiovascular disease, uncontrolled hypertension, arrhythmia, recent cardiac event: The fast-breathing phase produces a sympathetic surge. In someone with an underlying cardiac condition, that surge can be clinically significant. Action: Cardiologist clearance required. Default to no.\n- Seizure disorder or history of hyperventilation-induced seizures: Hyperventilation is used routinely in EEG labs to provoke absence seizures. The mechanism is identical in a living room. Action: Avoid. Talk to a neurologist if you want to reconsider.\n- Severe panic disorder or PTSD with hyperventilation triggers: The sympathetic surge phase replicates the physiological state of a panic attack and can trigger one. Action: Trauma-informed clinician first.\n- Eating disorders with severe hypoglycemia or electrolyte instability: WHM practices (especially fasted) can destabilize blood glucose and electrolytes. Action: Screen with a clinician first.\n\nThe shallow-water blackout mechanism is worth understanding in detail. Craig's 1961 paper in the Journal of Applied Physiology (a canonical diving-medicine reference) showed that voluntary hyperventilation before a breath-hold does not meaningfully raise oxygen stores. What it does is suppress the CO2-driven respiratory drive, which is the signal that normally tells you to inhale before you lose consciousness. Silence it, and the practitioner can lose consciousness before the urge to breathe ever returns. The Divers Alert Network names voluntary hyperventilation before breath-hold as the primary avoidable cause of shallow-water blackout, and the Wim Hof organization's own published safety guidance lists \"never in or near water\" as rule one.\n\nAnd the seizure warning isn't hypothetical. Hyperventilation is one of the standard provocations used during routine EEG testing to unmask absence seizure activity, per American Clinical Neurophysiology Society technical standards.\n\nThe pregnancy guidance comes from a different kind of source. ACOG has not issued a WHM-specific statement, but its general committee opinion on exercise during pregnancy supports skipping activities with hypoxia or syncope risk.\n\nFinally, the screened-cohort trials. Buijze et al., 2019 (PLOS ONE, N=24 axial spondyloarthritis) ran an 8-week WHM training program and reported no serious adverse events. But the participants were screened against cardiovascular, seizure, and psychiatric conditions first, so the absence of adverse events is not evidence that the contraindications are over-cautious. And Almahayni and Hammond's 2024 systematic review in PLOS ONE concluded that most published WHM trials are small and run in healthy adult practitioners. The evidence base does not tell us the technique is safe for unscreened cardiovascular, pregnant, or seizure-prone readers.\n\n## Softer cautions that warrant a conversation with your doctor\n\n- Mild asthma. Slow breathing and resonance breathing are generally well-tolerated. Rapid-breathing protocols like WHM can trigger bronchoconstriction in some people.\n- Blood-pressure medications, beta blockers, or other heart-rate-altering drugs. The sympathetic surge phase can interact with these.\n- Recent surgery (chest, abdominal, cardiac). Wait for full clearance, then reintroduce gently.\n- Mild anxiety without diagnosed panic disorder. Slow breathing usually helps. WHM is a different animal.\n- Age 60 and above, or a family history of cardiac events. Not a ban, but a reason to start very slowly.\n\nThe Cleveland Clinic's patient-facing guidance on the Wim Hof Method echoes this picture, advising caution in anyone with cardiovascular, seizure, or psychiatric history.\n\n## Which sensations are expected, and which are warning signs\n\n- Tingling in hands, feet, or around the lips: Normal alkalosis response (ionized-calcium shift, Laffey and Kavanagh, 2002). Expected.\n- Mild lightheadedness during or after fast breathing: Cerebral vasoconstriction from lower CO2. Expected response, and sitting down resolves it.\n- Hand or jaw cramping (tetany): More pronounced alkalosis. Not medically dangerous in healthy adults but a clear signal of intensity. Stop this session.\n- Small involuntary movements during retention: Common at deeper retention, not harmful in healthy adults.\n- Chest pain or tightness: Possibly cardiac. Stop now. Emergency services if it persists.\n- Actual fainting or near-syncope: Cerebral hypoperfusion beyond the normal range. Stop. Emergency services if in water.\n- Panic symptoms: Sympathetic surge triggering a panic response. Stop. Box breathing to bring the system back.\n\nTetany is the most dramatic sensation most practitioners encounter. In a healthy adult, it isn't medically dangerous. It is a clean signal that this session has gone about as far as it should.\n\n## What to do if something goes wrong mid-session\n\n- Mild lightheadedness: Stop the fast-breathing phase. Sit or lie down. Breathe normally for one to three minutes.\n- Tetany or muscle cramping: End the session. Normal breathing reverses the alkalosis within minutes.\n- Near-fainting or full syncope: Lie down with your legs raised. Emergency services if in water. Do not practice alone for 24 hours.\n- Panic symptoms: Stop. Switch to box breathing and use a grounding exercise.\n- Chest pain: Stop. Assume cardiac until proven otherwise. Emergency services if persistent.\n\n## When to call a doctor before trying again\n\n- Any chest pain during or after a session, ever.\n- Recurring lightheadedness or pre-syncope even during slow breathing.\n- Pregnancy, especially high-risk.\n- Known cardiovascular condition without prior clearance for breath-holds.\n- Panic disorder, PTSD, or trauma history without a trauma-informed clinician.\n- Seizure disorder or first-degree family history of seizures.\n- Breathwork making symptoms worse over time instead of better.\n\n## Safety across the major techniques\n\n- Box breathing (4-4-4-4): Safe for nearly everyone.\n- 4-7-8 breathing: Also safe for most people. The long exhale can occasionally feel triggering for panic-prone practitioners.\n- Resonance or coherent breathing (around 6 breaths per minute): The most gently tolerated of the slow patterns.\n- Rapid-breathing pranayama (bhastrika, kapalabhati): Shares several WHM contraindications. Traditional guidance recommends learning these under supervision.\n- Breath-holds generally: Never in water, never to exhaustion, and never while driving.\n\n## How BreathSesh handles the Wim Hof problem\n\nBreathSesh labels Wim Hof as an advanced pattern and shows an in-app safety block on first use. The guided mode has fixed retention options (30, 60, or 90 seconds) so a beginner isn't tempted to push further. Freestyle mode is deliberately separated for experienced practitioners. Every pattern runs offline without an account.\n\n## The bottom line\n\nThe Wim Hof Method produces real physiological effects, which is exactly why a hard contraindication list exists for it. Dry-land practice in a screened, healthy adult is generally well-tolerated. Water practice is not safe. Neither is pregnancy. Neither are the cardiovascular, seizure, and severe-panic populations. If you're unsure which category you fall into, that alone is a reason to start with slow diaphragmatic breathing and talk to a clinician before you touch the fast-breathing phase.","metaTitle","metaDescription","Wim Hof breathing is unsafe in water, during pregnancy, and with cardiovascular conditions. The full safety picture, with sources.","ogImageUrl","/images/blog/20-ice-bath-snowy-forest.webp","authorId",2,"categoryId","status","published","publishedAt",["D",1776499815906],"updatedAt",["D",1776499815906],"createdAt",["D",1776499815906],"readingTimeMinutes",10,"isFeatured",true,"viewCount",0,"author",{"_8":29,"_10":47,"_48":49,"_50":51,"_52":53,"_54":55,"_56":57,"_58":-5,"_59":60,"_61":-5,"_37":62,"_35":63},"dr-mia-chen","name","Dr. Mia Chen","bio","Mia holds a PhD in Respiratory Physiology and spent six years in academic research on autonomic nervous system function before moving to science communication. At BreathSesh she covers the physiology of breathwork, the research literature, and all safety content. She reads studies so you don't have to.","avatarUrl","/images/authors/dr-mia-chen.jpg","jobTitle","PhD Physiology, Science Editor","company","BreathSesh Editorial","twitterHandle","linkedinUrl","https://linkedin.com/in/dr-mia-chen-physiology","websiteUrl",["D",1776499815906],["D",1776499815906],"category",{"_8":29,"_10":66,"_48":67,"_68":69,"_23":70,"_24":71,"_72":-5,"_37":73},"safety","Safety","description","When breathwork is and is not safe, and what to watch for.","Breathwork Safety: Contraindications, Wim Hof, Pregnancy, More","Clear guidance on breathwork safety. Contraindications for Wim Hof, pregnancy, cardiovascular conditions, and more.","parentId",["D",1776499815906],"currentPage","totalPages","siteName","BreathSesh","actionData","errors"]